Google dropped a bomb on advertisers in 2022, and if you’re still scratching your head about Smart Shopping migration, you’re not alone. The transition from Smart Shopping campaigns to Performance Max has left many marketers—from scrappy entrepreneurs to seasoned digital veterans—wondering what just happened to their carefully optimized campaigns.
Let’s cut through the noise and talk about what this migration actually means for your business, why Google forced everyone’s hand, and how you can navigate this change without tanking your ROI.
What Exactly Is This Smart Shopping Migration Everyone’s Talking About?
If you’ve been running Google Ads for your e-commerce business, you probably got cozy with Smart Shopping campaigns. They were Google’s automated solution that combined Standard Shopping and display remarketing into one streamlined campaign type. You’d set your budget, upload your product feed, add some creative assets, and Google’s machine learning would handle the rest—bidding, placements, audience targeting, the whole nine yards.
Then Google decided it was time for an upgrade.
Starting in 2022, Google began automatically migrating Smart Shopping campaigns to Performance Max (PMax). By September 2022, the transition was mandatory for everyone. No exceptions, no grandfathering, no “I’ll do it later.” If you had Smart Shopping campaigns running, they got converted whether you liked it or not.
The Smart Shopping migration wasn’t just a rebrand or a minor feature update. It represented a fundamental shift in how Google approaches automated advertising. Performance Max takes the automation concept and cranks it up several notches, giving you access to all of Google’s inventory—YouTube, Display, Search, Discover, Gmail, and Maps—all from a single campaign.
Why Did Google Force This Migration?
Google isn’t known for making changes just for kicks. The Smart Shopping migration served several strategic purposes, and understanding them helps you grasp what you’re working with now.
First, consolidation. Google had too many campaign types doing similar things. Smart Shopping, Local campaigns, Smart Display—all these automated formats were creating confusion and fragmentation. Performance Max unifies them under one umbrella, which (theoretically) makes life simpler for advertisers and gives Google more control over ad delivery.
Second, inventory expansion. Smart Shopping was limited to Google Shopping and Display networks. Performance Max throws open the doors to YouTube, Discover, Gmail, and Search. Google wants your ads everywhere, and they’ve built the infrastructure to make that happen automatically.
Third, data and machine learning. More touchpoints mean more data. More data means better machine learning models. Better models mean (again, theoretically) better performance. Google’s betting that by feeding their algorithms information from across their entire ecosystem, they can deliver superior results compared to channel-specific campaigns.
Fourth, and let’s be honest here, revenue. When your ads run across more placements with less manual control, Google has more opportunities to serve impressions and collect clicks. It’s not cynical to acknowledge that Google benefits financially from this migration—it’s just business reality.
What Changed When Your Campaigns Migrated?
The Smart Shopping migration brought significant changes to how your campaigns operate. Some are improvements, some are trade-offs, and some are just… different.
Expanded reach is the headline feature. Your products can now appear in places they never could with Smart Shopping. Scrolling through YouTube Shorts? Your product might pop up. Checking Gmail? There’s your ad. Exploring Google Discover? You’re in the mix. This broader distribution can drive incremental conversions you wouldn’t have captured before.
Asset diversity is another major shift. Smart Shopping required product images from your feed plus optional text assets. Performance Max demands more: headlines, descriptions, images, videos, logos. The system mixes and matches these assets across placements, creating thousands of ad variations. This flexibility can improve performance, but it also means more work upfront building a robust asset library.
Reporting transparency took a hit—or improved, depending on who you ask. Smart Shopping was notoriously opaque about where your ads showed and which searches triggered them. Performance Max is… also pretty opaque, but in slightly different ways. You get asset performance reports and insights into audience segments, but granular search term data remains limited. If you’re someone who likes to micromanage every detail, this loss of control can be frustrating.
Audience signals replaced audience targeting. In Smart Shopping, you could exclude audiences but not specifically target them. Performance Max lets you provide “signals”—hints about who might convert—but the algorithm isn’t required to listen. It uses your signals as a starting point, then explores beyond them. This can uncover unexpected high-performing segments, or it can lead to wasted spend on irrelevant audiences.
Budget efficiency supposedly improved. Google claims Performance Max delivers better results at the same spend because the algorithm optimizes across more inventory and signals. Real-world results vary wildly. Some advertisers see immediate improvements. Others watch their CPA spike and their ROAS crater. The truth is that success depends heavily on your specific business, products, competition, and how well you set up the campaign.
The Real Talk About Performance Max vs. Smart Shopping
You’ll find plenty of articles that paint Performance Max as either a miracle solution or a complete disaster. Reality lives somewhere in the middle.
Performance Max genuinely works well for certain businesses. If you have a broad product catalog, healthy profit margins, clear conversion tracking, and you’re willing to let Google’s automation do its thing, PMax can drive solid results. The cross-channel approach does find customers you might miss with manual campaigns, and the machine learning does get smarter over time (if you feed it enough data).
But it’s not perfect, and the Smart Shopping migration forced many advertisers into a system that doesn’t suit their needs.
Small budgets struggle with Performance Max. The algorithm needs data to optimize, and if you’re only spending $20-30 per day, it takes forever to gather enough signal. You might burn through weeks of budget before the campaign starts performing decently.
Niche products face challenges too. If you sell specialized items with limited search volume, Performance Max might waste spend chasing irrelevant impressions across Google’s network instead of focusing on the small pool of qualified searchers.
Control freaks (and I mean that affectionately) find Performance Max maddening. If you built your career on meticulous keyword selection, bid adjustments, and placement optimization, handing everything over to a black-box algorithm feels like losing your job to a robot.
How to Actually Make Smart Shopping Migration Work for You
Complaining about the migration doesn’t change the reality that it happened and you need to deal with it. Here’s how to set yourself up for success with Performance Max.
Feed quality matters more than ever. Your product feed is the foundation of everything. Optimize your titles with relevant keywords, write compelling descriptions, use high-quality images, and keep pricing competitive. Performance Max pulls from this feed constantly, so garbage in means garbage out. Clean, detailed, accurate feed data gives the algorithm better ammunition.
Build a strong asset library. Don’t just upload the minimum required assets. Create multiple headlines (aim for 15), various description lengths (4-5 at least), several images showcasing different angles and contexts, and yes, videos if you can swing it. Google’s system tests combinations to find winners, so give it plenty of options to work with.
Set appropriate conversion goals. Performance Max optimizes toward whatever conversion actions you tell it to. If you track too many low-value actions (newsletter signups, account creations), the algorithm might prioritize those over actual sales. Focus on revenue-generating conversions and assign appropriate values to each.
Use audience signals strategically. Think of signals as guardrails, not handcuffs. Include your existing customer lists, website visitors, and any custom segments that historically convert well. But don’t overthink it—the algorithm will expand beyond your signals anyway. Start with solid signals, then let the system explore.
Be patient with the learning phase. Google recommends 6-8 weeks for Performance Max to fully optimize. That’s not marketing speak—it’s genuinely how long it takes to gather data, test variations, and stabilize performance. Resist the urge to make big changes every few days. Let it run, monitor the trends, and only adjust when you see consistent patterns over weeks, not days.
Monitor your search term insights. While you can’t see all search terms like you could with traditional Search campaigns, Performance Max does provide some insight reports. Check them regularly to spot irrelevant categories or brand terms you might want to exclude. Add negative keywords at the account level to prevent obviously bad matches.
Test different bid strategies. Most people start with Target ROAS or Maximize Conversion Value, which makes sense for e-commerce. But if you’re just starting or have limited data, Maximize Conversions might work better initially. Don’t be afraid to experiment—just change one thing at a time and give it adequate time to assess results.
Common Mistakes People Make After Smart Shopping Migration
Watching advertisers navigate this transition, certain mistakes pop up repeatedly. Avoid these and you’ll be ahead of the game.
Panic adjustments are the biggest killer. Someone migrates from Smart Shopping, sees different performance in week one, and immediately starts changing budgets, bids, assets, and settings. This resets the learning phase and creates a vicious cycle where the campaign never stabilizes. Make data-driven changes based on significant time periods, not knee-jerk reactions to daily fluctuations.
Insufficient budget hamstrings the algorithm. Performance Max needs room to test and learn across multiple channels. If your budget is so tight that you’re only getting a handful of clicks per day, the system can’t gather meaningful data. Either consolidate budgets from other campaigns to give PMax a real shot, or consider whether automated campaigns are right for your situation.
Ignoring asset performance leaves money on the table. Google provides reports showing which headlines, images, and descriptions perform best. Use this intel. Pause or replace underperforming assets, create more variations similar to your winners, and continuously refresh your creative to combat ad fatigue.
Running PMax in isolation without other campaigns can be risky. Many successful advertisers run Performance Max alongside Standard Shopping or Search campaigns, using different targeting or products for each. This creates some redundancy, but it also gives you data to compare and fallback options if one campaign type struggles.
Forgetting about landing pages. You can have perfect campaigns, but if your product pages are slow, confusing, or unconvincing, conversions will suffer. The Smart Shopping migration doesn’t change this fundamental truth. Invest in your website experience—clear product information, easy checkout, mobile optimization, trust signals like reviews and return policies.
Future-Proofing Your Approach
Google isn’t done evolving its advertising platform. Performance Max will continue to change, and the only certainty is that automation and machine learning will play increasingly central roles.
Stay educated on updates. Google regularly tweaks Performance Max features, reporting capabilities, and best practices. Follow official Google Ads channels, reputable industry blogs, and participate in communities where advertisers share real-world experiences.
Diversify beyond Google. While Performance Max might be mandatory for Google Shopping, don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Test Meta ads, TikTok, Pinterest, or other platforms relevant to your audience. Platform diversification protects you from algorithm changes and gives you leverage.
Build first-party data. As privacy regulations tighten and third-party cookies disappear, your own customer data becomes invaluable. Grow your email list, implement proper conversion tracking, and create detailed customer segments. This data feeds Performance Max and makes your campaigns more effective over time.
Focus on fundamentals. Automation handles tactics, but strategy remains human. Know your unit economics, understand your customer journey, differentiate your products, and communicate clear value propositions. Great marketing fundamentals make any campaign type work better.
The Bottom Line on Smart Shopping Migration
The Smart Shopping migration wasn’t optional, and dwelling on what you’ve lost wastes energy. Performance Max is your reality now if you’re advertising e-commerce products on Google.
Is it perfect? No. Does it give you less granular control than some advertisers want? Absolutely. Can it still drive profitable growth for your business? Yes—if you approach it thoughtfully, set it up properly, and give it time to work.
The advertisers who succeed with Performance Max after Smart Shopping migration share common traits: they focus on controllable factors like feed quality and asset creation, they make patient data-driven decisions, and they treat the algorithm as a tool rather than a magic bullet or an enemy.
Google’s automation improves each year, but it still needs quality inputs and strategic direction from actual humans. Your job hasn’t disappeared—it’s evolved. Instead of manually adjusting bids on thousands of keywords, you’re now curating assets, analyzing performance patterns, and making higher-level strategic decisions about targeting and positioning.
The migration happened. You adapted. Now it’s time to optimize and grow. Set up your Performance Max campaigns with care, monitor them intelligently, and keep testing to find what works for your specific business. The landscape changed, but the goal remains the same: reaching the right customers with the right message at the right time, and doing it profitably.
That’s what Smart Shopping tried to do, and it’s what Performance Max aims to do better. Whether it succeeds for your business depends largely on how you implement it. Get the setup right, give it time, and stay strategic. You’ve got this.
Paid Advertising Advanced: The Real Strategy Behind 7-Figure Ad Campaigns
